Harness or collar: which is better for a dog?

It is one of the most frequently asked questions among those who have just adopted a dog: harness or collar? There are those who swear by the collar being more practical and others who wouldn't dream of walking their dog without a harness under any circumstances. The reality is that there is no single answer; it depends on the dog, how you use it, and even the stage they are in.

Let’s compare both honestly, without selling you one as "the good one" and the other as "the bad one," so you can decide based on what your dog truly needs.

Why is there so much confusion between a harness and a collar?

Much of the confusion comes from the fact that both serve different functions and are compared as if they were interchangeable. The collar is, above all, the support for identification (tag, address) and works well for dogs that walk calmly by your side. The harness, on the other hand, is designed to control and direct the dog's body during the walk, distributing the force across the chest instead of the neck.

When a dog pulls hard on the leash with a collar on, all that pressure is concentrated on the trachea, an especially delicate point. For this reason, many families eventually switch to a harness almost out of necessity, without having planned it from the beginning.

How to know which one your dog needs?

Some clues to help you decide:

If your dog pulls hard on the leash, a harness reduces the risk of neck injury.
If they cough or make strange noises when pulling, it is a clear sign that the collar is affecting their trachea.
Small breeds or those with delicate tracheas (like Chihuahuas or Pugs) especially benefit from a harness.
Very calm dogs that walk right next to you can walk comfortably with just a collar.
If your dog is an escape artist or gets scared easily, a harness offers more security because it is much harder for them to wiggle out of it.

Practical solutions you can apply at home

A very practical option, and the one we recommend in most cases, is to combine both: a daily-use collar with an identification tag (in case they slip out or get lost) and a specific harness for walks, where the leash is attached.

If your dog already wears a collar and you want to introduce the harness without causing resistance, do it progressively: leave it on for a few minutes at home, without the leash, associated with treats, before using it on the first real walk.

And if the problem is that they pull a lot on the leash, changing the accessory is not enough: it is advisable to work on walking in parallel with positive reinforcement, rewarding them when they walk by your side without tightening the leash.

How to choose the right product

For the collar, prioritize soft materials that do not chafe (nylon with lining or synthetic leather), with a sturdy buckle and a firm ring for the identification tag. For the harness, look for double adjustment points, padding on the chest and belly, and an attachment ring that does not sit over the trachea.

At Huellas Perfectas, we have the Nylon and Leather Dog Collar, comfortable for daily use and available in various sizes and colors, and the No-Pull Dog Harness, designed for walks where you need more control and security. If you prefer not to choose between one or the other, we also have the Matching Harness and Collar Kit, so you have both taken care of from the start.

Errors you should avoid

Never attach the leash to a collar if your dog habitually pulls hard: the risk of neck injury is real, not just a remote possibility. Also, do not buy a harness or collar just for aesthetics without checking the actual fit on your dog. And avoid leaving the collar on permanently without checking it: fur can get trapped or the skin can become irritated if it is not adjusted as the dog grows.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use a collar and harness at the same time?
Yes, in fact, it is one of the safest combinations: a collar with an identification tag and a harness to attach the leash.

Does a harness make my dog pull more?
Not necessarily, but a poorly chosen harness (without front control) can make it easier for them to pull since they don't feel the same discomfort as they would with a collar.

At what age can a puppy use a harness?
From the moment they start going for walks, always with a model that is adjustable to their growth and by checking the fit every few weeks.

Compare harness models, collars, and combination kits at huellasperfectas.com.

Written by Huellas Perfectas

Thousands of happy pets, even happier owners ☺

"I'm very happy with my purchase. You can tell these products are designed with pets' wellbeing in mind, not just their appearance. The quality exceeded my expectations, and my dog settled in from day one. I'll definitely be shopping here again."

"I found exactly what I was looking for for my cat. The product arrived in perfect condition, and the quality is excellent. I really like that Huellas Perfectas offers practical products that genuinely make everyday life better for our pets."

"I bought a harness along with a few accessories, and the whole experience was excellent. The materials feel durable, the design is beautiful, and my dog is much more comfortable during walks. You can really see the care that goes into selecting their products."

"This is a store you can trust. I was delighted to find such a great selection of products focused on the wellbeing of both dogs and cats, with practical, high-quality options. Everything arrived exactly as shown on the website, and the shopping experience was simple and hassle-free."

"After trying different pet stores, Huellas Perfectas has become one of my favourites. The products offer excellent value for money, and it's clear they are committed to providing solutions that make our pets' lives more comfortable and happier. Highly recommended."